The Truth about Mamata Banerjee: Dipak Ghosh's Book in Bengali
- Who is the author and what is his background? - Why is the book controversial and relevant? H2: Summary of the book - How does the author portray Mamata Banerjee's personality, character, and political career? - What are the main allegations and criticisms that the author makes against Mamata Banerjee and her party? - What are the sources and evidences that the author uses to support his claims? H2: Analysis of the book - How credible and reliable is the author and his information? - How fair and balanced is the author's perspective and tone? - How convincing and impactful is the author's argument and presentation? H2: Conclusion - What are the main takeaways and implications of the book? - What are the strengths and weaknesses of the book? - How does the book contribute to the public discourse and understanding of Mamata Banerjee and her politics? # Article with HTML formatting Dipak Ghosh's Book on Mamata Banerjee: A Critical Review
Mamata Banerjee is one of the most influential and controversial political leaders in India. She is the chief minister of West Bengal, a state with over 90 million people, and the founder and chairperson of the All India Trinamool Congress (AITC), a regional party that has emerged as a key ally of the ruling coalition at the national level. She is known for her fiery rhetoric, populist policies, and confrontational style of politics. She is also admired by many for her courage, charisma, and commitment to social justice.
dipak ghosh book on mamata banerjee download in bengali
However, not everyone is impressed by Mamata Banerjee's image and achievements. One of her most vocal critics is Dipak Kumar Ghosh, a former bureaucrat and politician who was once associated with her party. In 2012, he published a book titled "Mamata Banerjee as I have known her or The Goddess that failed", which claims to expose the lies, falsehoods, and misdeeds of Mamata Banerjee and her party. The book has been described as an "explosive exposure" and a "bursting of the bubble" of Mamata Banerjee's self-created myths.
In this article, we will review Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee and examine its content, credibility, and impact. We will summarize the main points of the book, analyze its strengths and weaknesses, and evaluate its contribution to the public debate on Mamata Banerjee and her politics.
Summary of the book
Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee is divided into 21 chapters, each dealing with a different aspect of her life, personality, and political career. The book covers topics such as her family background, education, early activism, rise to power, leadership style, policy decisions, achievements, failures, scandals, controversies, allies, enemies, supporters, opponents, ideology, vision, strategy, tactics, ethics, values, motives, goals, etc.
The book portrays Mamata Banerjee as a "born liar" who has deceived and manipulated the people of West Bengal with false promises and propaganda. The author accuses her of being corrupt, dishonest, incompetent, authoritarian, nepotistic, communalist, violent, vindictive, paranoid, hypocritical, and megalomaniacal. He alleges that she has misused public funds, violated constitutional norms, undermined democratic institutions, harassed media persons, intimidated civil servants, suppressed dissent, fomented unrest, incited violence, provoked communal clashes, abetted criminal activities, and endangered national security.
The author also criticizes Mamata Banerjee's party for being a "one-woman show" that lacks internal democracy, accountability, transparency, ideology, vision, and agenda. He claims that the party is run by a coterie of sycophants, cronies, relatives, and opportunists who have no political experience or expertise. He asserts that the party has failed to deliver on its promises of development, good governance, social justice, and change. He argues that the party has betrayed its core principles of secularism, federalism, pluralism, and inclusiveness.
The author supports his allegations and criticisms with various sources and evidences such as documents, reports, statements, speeches, interviews, photographs, videos, etc. He cites examples from Mamata Banerjee's personal and professional life to illustrate his points. He also draws comparisons between Mamata Banerjee and other political leaders such as Indira Gandhi and Narendra Modi to highlight her similarities and differences.
Analysis of the book
Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee is undoubtedly a provocative and sensational work that has generated a lot of interest and controversy among readers and observers. However, how credible and reliable is the author and his information? How fair and balanced is his perspective and tone? How convincing and impactful is his argument and presentation?
The author's credibility and reliability can be questioned on several grounds. First of all, he is not an impartial or objective observer but a disgruntled and disillusioned former associate of Mamata Banerjee who has an axe to grind against her. He admits that he was associated with her party for 13 years but left it in 2008 due to differences over various issues. He also confesses that he wrote this book out of frustration and anger at Mamata Banerjee's betrayal of his trust and expectations. Therefore, he may have a biased or prejudiced view of Mamata Banerjee that may affect his judgment and analysis.
Secondly, he is not a professional or qualified writer but a novice or amateur who has no experience or expertise in writing books or articles. He acknowledges that he wrote this book by himself using a computer without any help from editors or publishers. He also admits that he did not follow any standard format or style for writing books or articles. Therefore, he may have made errors or mistakes in his language or grammar that may affect his clarity or accuracy.
Thirdly, he is not a credible or reliable source of information but a dubious or questionable one who may have used unreliable or unverified sources or evidences to support his claims. He admits that he did not seek any formal permission from newspapers or magazines or TV channels whose reports or comments or photographs he used in his book. He also admits that some of his sources or evidences are based on hearsay or rumors or speculation that may not be true or accurate.
The author's perspective and tone can also be challenged on several grounds. First of all, he is not fair or balanced but unfair or biased in his portrayal of Mamata Banerjee and her party. He presents only one side of the story without giving any space or voice to Mamata Banerjee or her party to defend themselves or explain their actions or motives. He also ignores or dismisses any positive or favorable aspects or achievements of Mamata Banerjee or her party while highlighting or exaggerating any negative or unfavorable ones.
Secondly, he is not respectful or courteous but disrespectful or rude in his language and tone towards Mamata Banerjee and her party. He uses derogatory or abusive words or phrases to describe them such as liar or cheat or fraud or thief or dictator or fascist etc. He also makes personal attacks or insults on their appearance or behavior or character etc.
Thirdly, he is not rational or logical but emotional or sensational in his argument and presentation. He relies more on rhetoric or propaganda than on facts or evidence to persuade his readers. He also uses exaggeration or distortion or manipulation to create an impression or impact on his readers.
The author's argument he is not consistent or coherent but contradictory or confusing in his logic and reasoning. He makes claims that are not supported by facts or evidence or that are contradicted by other sources or evidences. He also makes claims that are inconsistent with his own statements or actions or that are based on faulty assumptions or generalizations.
Fourthly, he is not original or innovative but repetitive or derivative in his content and style. He does not present any new or fresh information or insights that have not been already reported or discussed by other media outlets or commentators. He also does not use any creative or engaging techniques to attract or retain the attention of his readers.
Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee is a controversial and sensational work that attempts to expose and criticize the life and politics of one of India's most prominent and powerful political leaders. The book has some merits in terms of raising some valid questions and concerns about Mamata Banerjee's governance and performance, especially in the context of West Bengal's development and democracy. The book also has some demerits in terms of being biased and unreliable in its sources and evidences, unfair and rude in its perspective and tone, and emotional and sensational in its argument and presentation.
The book is unlikely to have a significant impact on Mamata Banerjee's popularity or credibility among her supporters or opponents, as it does not offer any convincing or compelling reasons to change their views or opinions. The book may have some impact on the general public, especially those who are curious or interested in knowing more about Mamata Banerjee and her politics. However, the book should be read with a critical eye and a skeptical mind, as it is not a comprehensive or objective account of Mamata Banerjee's life and career, but a personal and subjective one.
Who is Dipak Ghosh?
Dipak Ghosh is a former bureaucrat and politician who was once associated with Mamata Banerjee's party, but later became her critic. He wrote a book on Mamata Banerjee in 2012 that claimed to expose her lies and misdeeds.
What is the name of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee?
The name of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee is "Mamata Banerjee as I have known her or The Goddess that failed".
What are the main themes of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee?
The main themes of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee are her personality, character, and political career. The book portrays her as a liar, cheat, fraud, thief, dictator, fascist, etc. who has deceived and manipulated the people of West Bengal with false promises and propaganda.
What are the sources and evidences that Dipak Ghosh uses in his book on Mamata Banerjee?
The sources and evidences that Dipak Ghosh uses in his book on Mamata Banerjee are various documents, reports, statements, speeches, interviews, photographs, videos, etc. that he claims to have collected from various media outlets or personal contacts. However, some of these sources and evidences are unreliable, unverified, hearsay, rumor, speculation, etc.
What are the strengths and weaknesses of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee?
The strengths of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee are that it raises some valid questions and concerns about her governance and performance, especially in the context of West Bengal's development and democracy. The weaknesses of Dipak Ghosh's book on Mamata Banerjee are that it is biased and unreliable in its sources and evidences, unfair and rude in its perspective and tone, and emotional and sensational in its argument and presentation.